[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Thinkpad 760ELD Experience
Not wanting to make you feel discourage but here's the long story on my
experience with the 760ELDs:
I got this machine since it was the only thing available with
reasonable price and delivery time from CompUSA. The first unit showed
up without the correct power cord or the Lotus suite CD-ROM. It also had
a few bad pixels on the LCD display and does not want to talk to my
Practical Peripherals Proclass v.34 PCMCIA fax modem if I put it in
suspend/resume mode. I'd have to reboot the machine to get it to
recognize the card and this is the same for a 3COM 3C589 PCMCIA Ethernet
adapter. Both of these cards worked fine with other Toshiba notebooks
and I've tried to upgrade the firmware on the cards as well as on the
IBM machine and the same problem still occur afterward. IBM tech support
didn't really have a good answer except to say that it could be
incompatible with the notebook????
So I managed to get it exchanged for another unit which did come with
all the right accessories and also has a slightly newer manufacturing
date. I also replaced the Practical Peripherals modem with a Hayes
Optima v.34 PCMCIA modem and it seemed to work better with the IBM
machine. It also behaved better with the 3COM card eventhough I didn't
make any changes.
The machine worked ok except that I have to save my work quite frequent
since it tends to lock up for some unknown reasons and I've tried to
upgrade all of the firmware and drivers that I could think of. I've even
re-installed Win95 a few times just to make sure that it's setup
correctly and got the latest service pack installed as well. It also
does not allow me to hot swap the CD-ROM and floppy drives in contrast
to the user manual. So I ordered the external floppy attachment through
CompUSA and it hasn't show up after 3 months.
Well, things got worse as I travelled with this machine. It constantly
locked up whenever I picked it up and move it around such as from the
desk to my lap or just hitting the backspace, return and cursors keys
sometimes. This problem is quite easily duplicated by just moving it
around. I contacted IBM and was told to do the self test in continuous
mode and then call back if there was any problem. I also removed the
extra memory card just in case it caused the problem but that was not
it. When I called them back 2 days later to follow up and gave them the
incident number, they didn't even have the number in the system and
suggested I send in the machine for repair since they haven't heard of
this problem before!!!
Since I bought the machine with extended warranty support from CompUSA,
I contacted them hoping they would be able to help but they said my
machine is still covered under IBM warranty so they'll have to follow
IBM support guidelines. So much for that!!!
Anyway, they said I'd get a shipping box to send in the notebook for
repair in a couple of days. Four days later, a person from TSS (IBM
support) showed up at my office for a on-site service call. However, he
was expecting to be fixing a Lexmark printer and not a Thinkpad but
asked to look at the machine anyway. He couldn't even dis-assembled the
keyboard assembly and gave up after one hour. It seemed they have
mis-communicated and he couldn't tell me what to do next except to give
me a number to call and find out.
When I called this number, the person at the other end promised to have
another rep come by and pick up the machine the next day. Afterward, he
called back and asked if I could ship it to them instead. I packed it up
and sent it to the TSS (IBM Easyserv) depot overnight for a 72 hours
turn around repair and included some instructions for how to contact me
via email, pager or phone and what the problems were since I needed it
back in a hurry. I had to call them twice a day and endured long holding
times to get status of the repair and was told that they had so many of
these high end machine in repair that no one was assigned to fix it
until three days later. Once it was assigned to a tech, he told me that
this is quite a common problem and the system board needed to be
replaced. The bad news is that the board is not available and he would
have to wait between 3-5 days but somehow he got a board later that day
and put it in. He promised I would get the machine back the next day
before 10am and I was glad to hear that.
Well, around noon the next day, nothing showed up so I called them to
find out what was going on. I spoke with one of the customer rep and she
said that she would find out. Two hours went by and she called back to
leave a message that the machine would be shipped that day and I should
get it the next afternoon. Since I was going out of town the next
morning, I called her back and left a message in trying to reroute the
package to where I was going to be but she never returned my call. I
called FedEx to have this done myself and they promised to have it
delivered at the new address the next day or the day after and charging
some more money for it.
I got to the hotel the next afternoon and found out the package
dind't make it so I had our shipping people called FedEx to get the
status. The FedEx woman said it went to the original delivery address
but they still have my package and would send it to me the next day.
However, I later found out that they actually dropped off the package at
my office earlier and didn't even know it. So much for those FedEx
commercials you see on TV!!!.
I finally got the notebook back the next afternoon and turned it on to
see if things were really fixed. After the self test, I got a screen
that I never seen before and the machine refused to boot up. I called
IBM and found out that the machine couldn't find any bootable devices
based on the error code and asked me to check for the drives presence.
It turned out that the hard drive had came loose for some reasons and
had to be pushed back down.
I thought this is going to work but found that the machine still have
the same problem as before in addition to a new one. No matter what I
tried, Win95 or DOS/WFW could not see the PCMCIA controller at all. I
had this problem before and was able to fix it by removing and
re-installed Win95 drivers but not this time. Again, I called IBM to
explain the situation but the person I spoke with couldn't offer any
help but gave me another 24 hours support number to call. I called this
number and got someone whom asked for my phone number and said he'll
call me back in 10 minutes. Well, half an hour went by and nobody called
so I decided to call again. This time, the phone just rang for about 10
minutes and I hang up. When I tried again a minute later, a recording
came on and said they were closed.
The next day, I called the TSS depot to discuss the problem and the only
solution they could offer is to have the machine send back in. For what
I just went through, it was not what I wanted to do unless they can give
me a loaner unit or have it replaced with another one which they said
no. They transferred my call to a tech rep who was supposed to be able
to help but all she did was to ask me the basic information and said
someone would call me back in a couple of hours. A few hours went by and
I got another call which again just to verify the machine serial number
and such but no help and a promise to be called back. At about 11:30
that night, a rep called and again was stumbled by the problem and
couldn't help since he was a hardware person and suggested that I call
the regular support line. I got a hold of a person at the support center
and explained to her what I had done trying to fix the PCMCIA problem
and dind't even want to mention about the lock up problem. After
searching their problem database, she cound't find any solutions so she
talked with someone else whom gave the standard suggestion of getting
the latest drivers and see how it works (like the "take two of these and
call me in the morning" type of responses). I asked her how I could do
anything since I can't use the PCMCIA modem and don't have access to a
external modem at the hotel but didn't get a reply. So I went back
trying to hack it by re-installing a bunch of differrent drivers and
finally got it to work. By this time, it was about 12:30 AM so I guess
Friday the 13 did have some effect on the machine. I got on the IBM web
site and downloaded the drivers they suggested and installed it but I
don't think it made any difference since there were no Win95 drivers.
I even went to the IBM booth at Atlanta N+I '96 last week and talked to
one of their booth staffers but she couldn't offer any immediate help
except to took down my information and promised someone would call.
I'm trying to work with the CompUSA account rep right now to see if he
could get me a replacement but am not holding my breath since they don't
seemed to be able to deliver either. I work for a Ethernet equipment
manufacturer that offer 24-hours advance replacement for everything from
a simple $20 transceiver up to a $5000 RMON probe with no questions
asked during the 5 years warranty. We also offer 2 hours response time
if you login to our Web site and request support or sales information.
I'd be glad to get rid of this "junkpad" and tell everyone I know not to
buy one of them because of what I've experienced.
Are you having second thoughts about your Thinkpad yet?
--
------------------------------------------------------
| John Pham Phone: (800) 422-7044 |
| Lantronix (714) 453-7107 |
| 15353 Barranca Parkway Fax: (714) 450-7226 |
| Irvine, CA 92718 Email: johnp@lantronix.com |
------------------------------------------------------