[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Notebooks
>Well let me add that I'm dissatisfied with the keyboard as well,
>and state why.
>- It is flimsy. When opened, the only real places you can grab
>to pick the computer up is the front (too much torque - danger
>of dropping), the keyboard (flimsy, feels like it might break
>off), and the back near the screen (very thin decorative plastic
>material that cracked the first time I did this).
Solution: close the computer before picking up! I think picking up the 701
by
its keyboard is a major source of trouble. (Reminds me of ex-US President
Johnson
and his beagles...)
>- It sticks out. It gets in the way of XJack style PCMCIA modem
>cards.
XJack is *also* an idea better on paper than in practice - it seems to
interfere with
lots of stuff.
>- It sticks out. It's fine if you use it on a desk. If you use
>it on a cluttered desk,
...is where it shines. You can fit the floppy *under* the wings, so that
the whole system will
fit in a small space (like a sliding desk drawer shelf or airplane tray
table); with the 560, I never
know where to put the floppy drive when I need it.
>That means I end up worrying about little things like that a
>lot, which is enough to make me want a different (solid) form
>factor for my next laptop.
Overall I think the *physical* construction of the 701 (case strength et al)
is much
better than the 560. For example, I think my 560's last trip to EasyServ
was due
to a solder failure due to case flexure (the case will curve visibly if you
pick it up from
one side while open).
>> As I said earlier, what hapened with the 701 was that it turned out
>> that people wanted bigger screens more than they wanted small form
>> factors. The 701 keyboard was seen as a way to reduce the form factor.
Yet HP continued to use the small-footprint/small screen form factor in
their 600/800,
and now the Libretto is all the rage. I'll bet that a 701 with a faster
processor, bigger HD, and
a pound shaved off the weight would sell well.
>> The idea of using it on a full size notebook was, as far as I know,
>> never seriously considered
My guess is that the 'thin' designers and the 'folding keyboard' designers
were two distinct, competing groups within IBM.
- David