[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: 28.8 PCMCIA modem recommendation
> Well, CDW is selling the Hayes Optima 28.8 w/ X-Jack for $299.
> Anyone use it?
I will be shortly...just placed the order yesterday after reading through
the latest issue of BYTE magazine. They did a review of PCMCIA (now
called PC Card) modems, with the results as follows:
1) Practical Peripherals ProClass 288
2) Hayes Optima 288
3) Megahertz V.34
All three of these modems sport the x-jack style connecter, so the
Megahertz is no longer the only ball game in town. Just to quickly
summarize BYTE's results, the Hayes had the highest throughput, the
Practical ProClass had the highest "interoperability" (a measure of
the likelihood of making a V.34 connection), and the Megahertz had
nothing special.
As has been previously pointed out in this thread, the Megahertz modem
only supports the V.34 standard, while the other two support both
V.34 and V.FC. Both the Practical and the Hayes modems use Rockwell
chipsets, while the Megahertz uses an AT&T chipset.
My decision to go with the Hayes was based upon its respectable test
scores along with its lower price, about $50 less than either 1 or 3
above. Also, for you OS/2er's out there, Hayes is the only
manufacturer which claims to support OS/2. This may be important
with respect to initialization strings for native OS/2 comm/fax
software.
Thanks to all who responded to my questions. I'll post my findings
once I get up and running.
Regards,
--
Karl E. Yeanoplos
Denver, CO
kyeanopl@den.mmc.com / key@csn.net